Do No Harm: New Jersey Strengthens Responsible Gaming Regulations

Calling New Jersey responsible gaming regulations the “gold standard,” state Attorney General Jennifer Davenport announced new regulations that create a step-by-step process to identify online problem gamblers in order to get them help and stop them from gambling in New Jersey. Meanwhile, it may not be a crime in the state if you gamble while you are underage.

Attorney General Jennifer Davenport and the Division of Gaming Enforcement (DGE) Interim Director Mary Jo Flaherty this week announced mandatory responsible gaming regulations that require online casinos and sports books operating in the state to identify problem gamblers by using data-drive resources.

“We are proud to enact regulations that require operators to offer resources, including live support if appropriate, to those struggling with problem gambling,” said Davenport. “We have a responsibility to keep the gaming industry accountable and ensure that help is available to those who need it.”

“We’re making it mandatory for operators to track their players and to act when appropriate and necessary. We need these robust protections because we’re seeing an explosion in retail and online casino games as well as sports betting. Ads are everywhere. You can gamble anywhere. But when you wager in New Jersey, you should be protected by our strict gaming laws.”

“These initiatives reflect DGE’s commitment to responsible gaming through practical, proven methods,” said Flaherty. “Our regulations identify and respond to gambling-related harm. When signs of problem gaming arise, operators must act to ensure early intervention and support, tiered to individual need.”

The new responsible gaming regulations require every operator to appoint a responsible gaming lead who is in charge of those efforts. Operators must employ a set of mandatory patron play thresholds and behavioral triggers to help identify players who may need support. Where customers meet those criteria, operators must engage in a due diligence review to determine whether the patron is exhibiting signs of potential problem gaming. If so, the operator must add the person to the operator’s list of at-risk players and apply three phases of interventions based on the operator’s assessment.

The DGE’s Responsible Gaming Coordinator Jamie McKelvey said the regulations are currently aimed at the online casinos and sports books, rather than the land-based properties.

“Online operators do have more access to information than the brick-and-mortar casinos do,” McKelvey explains. “These regulations do only apply to the online operators at this time. We are looking in the future, have similar aspects applied to the land-based brick-and-mortar casinos.”

Prediction Problems

Davenport recognized that upgrading responsible gaming regulations does no good for the prediction market companies that operate today in the state, flouting state gaming authority.

“That’s why it’s so problematic that Kalshi claims to offer legal sports betting in all 50 states, but refuses to follow state gaming laws,” she says. “And that’s why we are asking the U.S. Supreme Court to look at this question and hold that prediction markets are subject to state gaming laws.

“And we’re joined by a bipartisan coalition of 39 states and the District of Columbia, along with 146 tribal nations and tribal organizations and the NFL.”

When asked whether the state could bar Kalshi from operating in New Jersey as has occurred in Nevada and several other states, Davenport referenced the lawsuit.

“When we take a look at prediction markets, they’re offering a product that is indiscernible from what we maintain is sports wagering,” she says. “And our litigation is really to ensure that only operators licensed by the state of New Jersey and meeting our regulatory requirements here offer the sports wagering in our state.”

Flaherty explained it wasn’t possible because of some court decisions.

“We’re in a position with the litigation where there are court orders to the effect that we are not permitted to effectuate our cease and desist order, which is how this case started,” she says. “We went to take action against the operators to stop their activities, but they went to court and they convinced the court system to allow these cases to proceed while our cease and desist was placed on hold.”

On the legal side, there are licensed New Jersey operators that operate in the prediction markets, including DraftKings, FanDuel, Fanatics and others. Flaherty was reluctant to immediately call them out for conducting illegal gambling as prediction companies in other states.

“At this point,” she explains, “they are not offering the prediction markets within our state and that’s our primary jurisdiction. At the time of a license resubmission, we can definitely look at their activities and see if that type of conduct implicates their good character in terms of their activity in the laws of other states.”

Those companies are not out of the woods, however, when it comes to marketing to their VIP customers.

“We are monitoring recent press reports alleging certain sports books are ignoring our consumer safeguards and chasing customers who are clearly exhibiting signs of problem betting,” says Davenport. “Let them be warned, our office stands ready to take action against anyone who violates our gaming regulations and tries taking advantage of New Jerseyans and those who gamble here.”

Underage Attitudes

Another development in the state was separate from the recent responsible gaming announcement.

From the start of legal gambling in New Jersey, gambling by youth under 21 has been classified as a crime. But critics say the penalties were too harsh, so a move is under way in the state legislature to change the categorization and penalties.

There’s a bill under consideration where anyone under 21 caught gambling in a casino, racetrack or simulcasting facility would be charged civilly and fined up to $500 for the first offense, up to $1,000 for the second offense and $2,000 for a third offense. All fines would be used for prevention, education, and treatment programs for compulsive gambling, such as those provided by the Council on Compulsive Gambling of New Jersey.

Senator Vince Polistina, who represents the Atlantic City region, is one of the bill’s sponsors.

“Gambling has become a much bigger part of everyday life, from sports broadcasts and commercials to social media and the constant stream of betting ads people see online,” he said. “Young people are exposed to it more than ever, and that should be taken into consideration when deciding how to handle underage gambling violations.

“Now, underage gambling should never be encouraged, and casinos have a responsibility to follow the law, but a criminal offense is an unnecessarily harsh consequence for a kid who makes a mistake,” Polistina said. “This bill keeps penalties in place, increases fines for repeat violations, and directs the money collected toward gambling addiction prevention, education, and treatment. We can hold people accountable while taking a more constructive approach that recognizes the world young people are growing up in and helps prevent future problems.”

The bill has advanced through several committees, but must be approved by majorities of both houses of the legislature and signed by the governor to become law.